Jimmy Garoppolo Wasn't Right Fit For Cardinals

Posted Nov 1, 2017

The 49ers took a home run swing before Tuesday’s trading deadline, acquiring promising quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo from the Patriots for a second-round pick. The bold move by the 49ers and the Cardinals’ lack of aggressiveness at the deadline exasperated fans, but that type of trade wouldn’t have made as much sense for the Cardinals.

The 49ers took a home run swing before Tuesday’s trading deadline, acquiring promising quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo from the Patriots for a second-round pick.

The move made sense on a couple of fronts for San Francisco. They have so much cap room that signing Garoppolo to a contract extension will only put a dent in it, and, as Paul Calvisi adroitly pointed out in our podcast this week, they can now trade their first-round pick in 2018 to a quarterback-needy team and get a bounty back to recoup their loss.

The bold move by the 49ers and the Cardinals’ lack of aggressiveness at the deadline exasperated fans, but that type of trade wouldn’t have made as much sense for the Cardinals.

Even if several high-priced veterans come off the books next offseason, the Cardinals aren’t going to have nearly as much cap space as the 49ers.They will still have high-priced stars like cornerback Patrick Peterson and outside linebacker Chandler Jones under contract, with running back David Johnson, left tackle D.J. Humphries and outside linebacker Markus Golden eligible for extensions.

A guy like Garoppolo is going to cost a pretty penny despite only two career starts to his name. If the Cardinals had traded for him and he became a Pro Bowler, then of course it would have been worth it. But if he became average or worse – Mike Glennon and Brock Osweiler both got paid handsomely before flaming out – it would have put the team in a bind.

“If you trade for a player who is a veteran and has not done it on a consistent basis yet, you’re still having to pay them ‘X’ amount of money, which is scary,” General Manager Steve Keim said on Arizona Sports 98.7 FM on Tuesday. “Whether you can put something in place contractually, which isn’t long-term guaranteed, you’re still talking about guys nowadays getting anywhere from 18-to-20 million dollars stamped based on a résumé, which isn’t very long.”

Fan anxiety is completely understandable right now, as the Cardinals still have not identified their quarterback of the future. But the best-case scenario continues to be hitting on one in the draft, because a rookie deal is peanuts compared to what Garoppolo will make.

“I would much rather draft and develop if you had your way,” Keim said. “Especially a young one that you believed in because you can grow with him. It not only helps you as a team (but) from a salary cap structure. You’re paying a guy minimal money and you can build a team around him.”

Latest By The Numbers

  • D.J. Foster Continues To Cruze

    Posted Dec 13, 2017

    Cardinals running back D.J. Foster is getting more financially comfortable by the week, but you’d never know it by the way he arrives at the team’s practice facility. Foster does so in a Chevy Cruze, a compact car his mom bought for him when he was in college at nearby Arizona State.

  • The Importance Of Field Position

    Posted Dec 11, 2017

    The Cardinals' defense has played excellent of late, but the scoring numbers don't totally reflect that because of variables outside of its control.

  • Feeding Ricky Seals-Jones

    Posted Dec 6, 2017

    Since taking over as the third tight end against the Texans, Ricky Seals-Jones has amassed nine catches for 170 yards and three touchdowns in three games. The numbers are impressive on their face, but even moreso when considering how little he has been on the field.

  • The Cardinals’ Defense Is Above Average

    Posted Dec 1, 2017

    The Cardinals’ defense started slowly this year and bottomed out against the Rams in Week 7. After the 33-0 loss in London, the team ranked 31st in the NFL in points allowed. The next week, the players spoke adamantly about the need to improve, and they have.

  • Backup Quarterbacks Keeping Cardinals Afloat

    Posted Nov 29, 2017

    The loss of a starting quarterback can torpedo a season faster than any other injury in football. The Cardinals, though, are getting solid performances from their backups.

Add Your Comment:

Guidelines: Please keep your comments relevant to the topic and appropriate. Abusive or combatant comments towards other fans will not be tolerated and will be removed from display on this site. Use the "Report Abuse" link to help keep the Cardinals community at its best.