The Return Game Candidates

Posted Aug 9, 2017

The Cardinals have some options to replace T.J. Logan because there is a lot of speed on the roster. However, returning is also about sound judgment and ball security. Kerwynn Williams is expected to get the first shot at both return jobs, but there will be competition.

After cycling through myriad return man options over the past four years, the Cardinals finally found their guy when rookie speedster T.J. Logan burst onto the scene in the Hall of Fame Game on Thursday.

That stability lasted less than four quarters, as Logan dislocated his wrist late in the contest and will miss 12 weeks. He could be back by midseason if the Cardinals choose to activate him off injured reserve, but for now, they are back to square one.

The return game has never been great during coach Bruce Arians’ tenure. The Cardinals have finished 31st, 32nd, 16th and 16th in kickoff return average since 2013. They have finished 31st, ninth, 24th and 30th in punt return average in those years.

There have been bright spots – David Johnson’s kick return touchdown in Chicago in 2015 and Ted Ginn’s punt return score against the Giants in 2014 – but not a lot of consistency.

It’s not an easy thing to address with small rosters and a limited pool of candidates. Johnson is probably the best kick returner on the roster and cornerback Patrick Peterson the best punt returner, but Arians doesn’t want to put them in harm’s way because of their value. (Same with safety Tyrann Mathieu, who was a return phenom at LSU but tore his ACL returning a free kick as a rookie.)

The Cardinals have some options because there is a lot of speed on the roster. However, returning is also about sound judgment and ball security. Kerwynn Williams is expected to get the first shot at both return jobs, but there will be competition. Below are the return histories of the main candidates for each job:



Kickoff return candidates
 ReturnsYardsAverageTD
Kerwynn Williams (NFL)
(Utah State)
9
135
154
3,408
17.1
25.2
0
1
Rudy Ford (Auburn) 24 574 23.9 0
J.J. Nelson (NFL)
(UAB)
2
76
53
1,932
26.5
25.4
0
1
 
Punt return candidates
 ReturnsYardsAverageTD
John Brown (NFL)
(Pittsburg State)
17
74
119
1,026
7.0
13.9
0
3
Kerwynn Williams (Utah State) 11 135 12.3 0
Chad Williams (Grambling) 6 44 7.3 0
J.J. Nelson (NFL)
(UAB)
4
35
13
375
3.3
10.7
0
1
Patrick Peterson (NFL)
(LSU)
173
27
1,664
424
9.6
16.1
4
2


Latest By The Numbers

  • Larry Fitzgerald’s Role At Wide Receiver

    Posted Apr 18, 2018

    Cardinals star learning outside responsibilities in addition to the slot under OC Mike McCoy

  • Haason Reddick And Budda Baker Settle In

    Posted Apr 4, 2018

    Second-year defenders looking forward to full offseason of work

  • Pay No Attention To Power Rankings

    Posted Mar 28, 2018

    Too much can change to put any stock into current projections

  • Quantifying Cardinals’ 2017 Injury Woes

    Posted Mar 26, 2018

    Offense had worst accumulation of injuries in NFL last season, per Football Outsiders

  • Sam Bradford's Market Value Contract

    Posted Mar 17, 2018

    There has been a rush in the past few days to equate the release of safety Tyrann Mathieu with the signing of quarterback Sam Bradford, but they are separate entities. While there is always sticker shock on the deals quarterbacks receive, that position is far and away the most important in the NFL, and teams must pay a premium because arm talent is scarce. If Bradford receives the reported maximum amount of $20 million in 2018, he will be the highest-paid player on the Cardinals -- but in the context of quarterbacks, it’s not an egregious amount.

Add Your Comment:

Guidelines: Please keep your comments relevant to the topic and appropriate. Abusive or combatant comments towards other fans will not be tolerated and will be removed from display on this site. Use the "Report Abuse" link to help keep the Cardinals community at its best.